
Published estimates are all over the map. Angi's 2026 data puts the average gas furnace replacement at $7,000, with most projects between $3,800 and $10,000. Fuel type, capacity, efficiency, ductwork, venting and local requirements drive the gap.
This guide separates equipment from installation and long-term costs. It also explains why quotes differ and how to build a realistic budget.
Key Takeaways
- Gas furnace replacement typically runs $3,800-$12,000 installed, a planning range rather than a quote.
- Capacity, AFUE, labor, ductwork, venting and permits move the price.
- Complex jobs and high efficiency can justify higher costs; simple swaps may not.
- The best budget balances safe installation, correct sizing and operating costs, not just the lowest bid.
How Much Does Furnace Replacement Cost? (Pricing Overview)
There is no fixed national price. Published figures differ because some include only the furnace, while others include labor, removal, permits and modifications.
Misreading the scope causes real problems: underbudgeting, an improperly sized unit, or surprise bills for ductwork, venting, electrical work, permits or a new thermostat.
Typical Installed Cost Range
Carrier's October 2026 guide lists gas furnaces at $3,800-$12,000, including the unit and professional installation. Extensive venting, duct or electrical changes can push a project past that.
Equipment-only prices, per Angi, run lower and should not be mistaken for installed totals:
| AFUE tier | Equipment only |
|---|---|
| Standard (80%-89%) | $500-$1,500 |
| Moderate (90%-95%) | $1,000-$3,000 |
| High-efficiency (96%+) | $2,000-$6,000 |
No source standardizes "basic, mid-range, high-end" installed tiers. Ask every contractor to spell out what is included:
- Equipment and labor
- Removal, permits and disposal
- Ductwork and thermostat
Furnace Cost by Type and Fuel
| Fuel | Published replacement range |
|---|---|
| Natural gas | $3,800-$12,000 |
| Electric | $2,000-$8,100 |
| Propane | $3,700-$14,200 |
| Oil | $6,750-$10,000+ |
Scopes aren't perfectly comparable across sources. Fuel availability, venting needs and local utility prices shape both upfront and ongoing costs.
Nationally, heating oil averaged $5.915 per gallon and propane $2.826 per gallon in November 2026, per EIA. In New York, residential electricity averaged 24.43 cents/kWh in 2024 versus 16.48 cents/kWh nationally.

A true heating-cost comparison needs your home's load, local rates and the furnace's AFUE.
Cost for a 2,000-Square-Foot Home
Angi's $7,000 average covers homes of 1,600-2,000 square feet, so treat it as a planning figure, not a 2,000-square-foot quote. NerdWallet links a 2,000-square-foot home to roughly 60,000-120,000 BTU, a wide span for a reason.
Square footage alone doesn't set capacity. Insulation, windows, climate, layout and ductwork do. ACCA's Manual J load calculation is the recognized standard, so ask your contractor for one.
Furnace and AC Replacement Together
Angi puts a combined furnace and central AC replacement at an average of $7,500 (range $5,000-$12,500). Shared labor, ductwork and controls can make bundling cheaper than separate projects.
Bundling isn't automatic, though. If your AC is in good shape, compare written bids for the combined and separate options.
Key Factors That Affect Furnace Replacement Cost
Your quote reflects equipment specs, heating needs, site conditions, labor, local codes, and expected performance.
Furnace Type and Configuration
Single-stage furnaces run at full output or off. Two-stage models run at lower output much of the time. Modulating models adjust in small increments.
Carrier says a two-stage unit averages $1,000-$2,500 more upfront than a comparable single-stage. In return you get steadier temperatures and quieter operation.
Capacity and Heating Load
BTU capacity affects price, but bigger isn't better. An oversized furnace short-cycles, heats unevenly and wears out faster. An undersized one can't keep up on cold days.
Insist on a professional load calculation, not a square-footage shortcut.
Efficiency and AFUE Rating
AFUE is the share of fuel converted into heat over a typical year. Per DOE's definition, a 90% AFUE furnace turns 90% of fuel into home heat and loses 10%.
Key points:
- Federal minimum for non-weatherized gas furnaces is currently 80% AFUE.
- A 95% AFUE standard applies to gas furnaces manufactured on or after Dec. 18, 2028; an industry petition seeks to delay it, but it remains in the current regulations.
- ENERGY STAR's northern criterion is 95% AFUE, relevant in New York.
- The federal 25C tax credit expired for property placed in service after Dec. 31, 2025.
Higher efficiency pays back best in cold climates, with high fuel prices and long run times.
Installation Complexity
Labor for gas furnaces runs $500-$2,000, with installers at $50-$100 per hour. These conditions often add time and cost:
- Tight access or difficult equipment paths
- Old-unit removal and disposal
- Startup, testing, and commissioning
- Switching furnace type or configuration
Existing Ductwork, Venting, Gas and Electrical Infrastructure
Condensing high-efficiency models may need different venting. Damaged ducts, new gas lines, condensate drainage, electrical circuits or thermostat compatibility can widen the scope.
Angi estimates a new gas line at $250-$800 and new ductwork at $1,500-$7,000. These apply only if your project needs them. Get every such item written into the quote.

Brand, Features, Timing, and Regional Pricing
Several other variables shape the final number:
- Warranty terms and parts availability
- Variable-speed blowers, smart thermostats, filtration, and zoning
- Local labor rates and seasonal timing
- Registration windows (Carrier's warranty, for example, depends on registering within 90 days)
Older Yonkers buildings can also have quirky layouts or no ductwork, which changes the scope.
Cost Breakdown of Furnace Replacement
The budget covers more than the furnace cabinet. Ask for an itemized estimate showing one-time, recurring and periodic costs.
Initial Equipment and Professional Installation
A complete install should cover:
- Old-unit removal and new connections
- Startup, safety checks and airflow verification
- A walkthrough of how the system works
Labor typically runs $500-$2,000.
Site-Specific Additions and Project Requirements
Published benchmarks, per Angi:
- Permits and inspections: $400-$1,500 (gas guide)
- Old-unit removal: $60-$500
- Thermostat installation: $120-$260
- Zoning: $2,000-$3,000
Venting, condensate drainage and electrical upgrades vary widely by home, so get itemized local bids for those line items. Yonkers' posted fee schedule dates to 2019, so confirm current permit costs locally.
Operating Costs and Maintenance
Fuel type, AFUE, local rates, runtime and insulation drive lifetime cost. Savings estimates aren't guarantees.
- Annual tune-up: $150-$200
- Filters (replace at least every 90 days): about $4-$140 a year
- Heat exchanger replacement: $500-$1,500
- Blower motor replacement: up to $2,000
- Igniter replacement: $150-$250

Upgrades, Replacement Parts, and Paired Systems
Smart thermostats, zoning, humidification, filtration and variable-speed equipment add cost. If your AC is also past 10-15 years, frequently repaired or inefficient, pairing the projects is worth pricing out.
Low-Cost vs. High-Cost Furnace Replacement: What's the Difference?
| Factor | Budget install | Premium install |
|---|---|---|
| Efficiency | 80%-89% AFUE | 95%+ AFUE |
| Comfort | Single-stage, on/off | Two-stage or modulating |
| Warranty | Standard 5-year parts | Extended options if registered |
| Long-term value | Lower upfront, higher fuel use | Higher upfront, lower fuel use |
Spend more only when the capacity, efficiency, comfort or installation work fits your home. A well-insulated house with mild needs may never recoup a premium unit.
How to Estimate the Right Budget
Use these steps to set a furnace replacement budget you can trust:
- Identify your heating load with a professional assessment so the system matches your home.
- Confirm which fuels are available at your address before you compare equipment.
- Request multiple itemized quotes that break out equipment, labor, and extras.
- Verify permits and warranty terms before you commit.
- Reserve a cushion for site-specific work such as duct or electrical upgrades.

Quality Comfort Solutions offers free, no-obligation installation estimates to homeowners in Yonkers and Westchester County, backed by licensed and insured HVAC services. Pricing is upfront, with no hidden fees.
What Most People Miss When It Comes to Furnace Replacement Cost
Equipment price isn't the project price. Ask whether labor, removal, permits, ductwork, venting, testing, thermostat work, and disposal are included.
The cheapest furnace isn't always the cheapest to own. Compare efficiency, maintenance, comfort, warranty, and parts availability against upfront price. Savings depend on fuel prices, runtime, and insulation.
The "$5,000 rule" is only a starting point. CBS News describes it as system age multiplied by repair cost; above $5,000 favors replacement. Also weigh:
- Furnace age (Carrier often favors replacement past 15 years or when repairs near 50% of a new system's value)
- Safety concerns and heat-exchanger condition
- Repair frequency and energy use
- The full replacement quote
Conclusion
Furnace replacement cost depends on equipment type, efficiency, capacity, labor, existing infrastructure, local requirements, and upgrades. A sound budget prioritizes safe installation, correct sizing, dependable comfort, and manageable operating costs.
Get a detailed professional assessment before committing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to replace a furnace?
Gas furnace replacement commonly runs $3,800-$12,000 installed, with an Angi average of $7,000. Final price depends on type, capacity, efficiency, labor and site conditions.
How much does a new furnace cost for a 2000 sq ft house?
Square footage alone can't set size or price. A load calculation, insulation, windows, climate, ductwork and efficiency decide it. Angi averages $7,000 for 1,600-2,000 square feet.
What is the labor cost to install a gas furnace?
Angi lists $500-$2,000, at $50-$100 per hour. Access, removal, venting, gas connections, permits and ductwork can raise it.
What is the $5000 rule for furnace?
The rule multiplies system age by repair cost; above $5,000 favors replacement. Use it as a budgeting rule of thumb, and also weigh safety, repair history, efficiency and remaining life.
How often should you replace a house furnace?
Well-maintained gas furnaces last 15+ years. Plan on replacement if you face frequent repairs, rising bills, uneven heating, unsafe operation or major component failure.
What is the best time of year to buy a furnace?
Late summer or early fall is often lower demand, though savings aren't guaranteed. Never delay replacement over a safety problem or total heating failure.